home about me books blog news links f.a.q. contact

Praise for The Weight of the Sky 

Named one of the New York Public Library's Books for the Teen Age, 2007
 
"Exquisitely written, The Weight of the Sky is an emotionally rich evocation of Israel that brings the land to vibrant life as a place where one American girl finds her self, her past, and her future. An unforgettably vivid, deeply satisfying reading experience."
— Michael Cart, founding editor, Rush Hour
 
Kirkus Reviews
This lovely first-person narrative told in poetry introduces Sarah, a 16-year-old who feels misplaced in the American suburban community that she inhabits. With the pressure of college choices ahead of her, Sarah begins to wonder about her choices and about who she really is. Because Sarah's parents understand this, they buy her a ticket to Israel for the summer. Love with an Israeli soldier, friendships with various teens and new experiences working on a kibbutz all move Sarah forward in her thinking about who she is and what her purpose might be. More than a few moments in this verse novel are poignant: Sarah's desperate attempt to understand the Israeli's complex feeling of compulsory army, friends who die in the ongoing conflict and the simple sensual pleasures of eating fruit off a tree are a few examples. Give this to teenage readers who are searching for perspective outside of themselves or as an alternative to the SAT grind. (Fiction. 12+)

School Library Journal
Gr 8 Up - Sarah Green, 16, is one of two Jewish students at her small Pennsylvania high school. A self-described band geek, she is tormented by the popular clique and overburdened by her feeling that her "religion is a conscious decision every day" of her life. When her parents offer to send her to Israel for the summer, she jumps at the chance to assert her independence, reinvent herself in a new place, and live and work on a kibbutz. While her journey to find herself is not without hardship and challenges, and her idealistic view of Israel and kibbutz life is shattered, Sarah survives the summer transformed, with a new sense of Jewish identity, a deeper connection to the land of Israel, increased self-confidence, and a more mature awareness of her own sexuality. The fast-paced, easy-to-read, free-verse narration captures the voice of a typical American teen. Sarah's coming-of-age experience could have happened during any summer camp or work experience, making the book accessible to a general teen audience.
 
KLIATT
Written in free-flowing verse, this is the story of a young American woman discovering her heritage as a Jew by spending a summer working on a kibbutz in Israel. As the only Jew in her class, Sarah is already "different," but her place in the high school social strata is defined by the "clunky, chunky red marching band jacket" that identifies her as a bona fide geek, ridiculed by the cheerleaders and relegated to the underclass of high school. The summer trip to Israel that her parents give her before her senior year is a way for Sarah to start fresh in a place that not only gives her a piece of her past, but shows her a direction for her future.

The beauty of the Israeli landscape is painted in carefully crafted poetry, but the tension and tentativeness of today's Israel is never far from the surface. Sarah learns about herself through the eyes of a foreign culture where she can clearly see the social layers and determine for herself where she chooses to fit in. By working the earth of her ancestors, Sarah carefully cultivates a new identity for herself, returning as a fully grown individual, comfortable with who she has become.                 
— Michele Winship, Asst. Prof., Capital Univ., Columbus, OH 

 
Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books
Recommended: Gr. 7-10
Dissatisfied with her chunky body, her cliquish high school, and her prosaic college plans, Sarah reluctantly takes up her mother's offer of a trip to Israel in the summer before senior year. From her initial visit with relatives to her arrival on a kibbutz, Sarah finds herself in the midst of a slightly older crowd, many of whom have completed requisite military service, and she is awed by their glamour and worldliness. Flattered by the attention of handsome soldier, Lior, she's delighted to discover she can be the object of romantic attention, even if it's infatuation for her and shallow flirtation for him. Likewise, arduous labor on the kibbutz hardens her body and builds her confidence. Mixed in with these somewhat typical coming-of-age themes, however, is Sarah's conflicted relationship with Israel itself. She's drawn to the land and smitten with the romance of its history but appalled by the almost casual acceptance of risk among its citizens and the problematic treatment of Palestinians that she observes in her travels, and if at one point she had fancied herself connected to some vague nobility of the Zionist founders, it quickly gave way to the harsh reality of pulling weeds under a scorching sun. Sarah narrates in free verse that veers between flights of spiritual exuberance and mundane comments on the cafeteria food. On the whole, however, the tonal shift is appropriate to Sarah's changeable moods, and although readers will hardly be surprised when Sarah flees the country after hearing that Lior has been killed, they will be even less surprised at her plan to attend Hebrew University and reconcile with her cultural roots.                                                                           
— Elizabeth Busch
 
The Jewish Week
Lisa Ann Sandell has written a long love poem to Israel in the form of a teen novel. “The Weight of the Sky” (Viking) is an altogether original coming-of-age story, a first novel written not in paragraphs but in lines broken up on the page like poetry, or free verse. Sarah, the 16-year-old narrator, lives in a small town in Pennsylvania; she’s one of two Jews in her class in a place where difference is neither accepted nor appreciated.

At her parents’ urging, she takes off for a summer in Israel, leaving behind the taunts of the cheerleading gang, school lunches of prohibited pork chops and the pressures of thinking about college. Soon after she arrives, she sits on the balcony of her cousin’s Jerusalem apartment, takes in the fragrant jasmine and begins to feel at peace, even as she’s nervous about this adventure. As she feels the breath of the city and its heartbeat, she at once knows she is part of the humming she hears.

On kibbutz, her memories of not being asked to dance at school events are far away. She trades in her overstuffed suitcase for used work clothes and joins the other volunteers in the fields and in after-work outings. For the first time, she feels she is not invisible and finds her voice, as though she is “awakening/ from a deep sleep/ of sixteen years.” She falls in love with an Israeli soldier, experiences the tragic death of another and is moved immeasurably by this land of “beautiful dreams/and nightmares.”

The title is drawn from a moment when she’s floating on her back on Lake Kinneret, looking up at the stars, feeling “the weight of the sky” pressing down on her with heavenly strength.

Although this is a book intended for teens, adults will also appreciate its charm and emotional reality. Sandell’s descriptions of Israel are finely rendered; many readers will remember their first wide-eyed trips to Israel in her telling. When asked in an interview about her choice of writing style, Sandell explains that Sarah’s voice came to her in this form. When she tried moving the lines around to make the novel read like prose, it didn’t work.

By day, Sandell is a book editor at Scholastic, and she writes at night and on weekends in her Upper West Side apartment. She says that one of the challenges in writing for teenagers is that they have so many distractions in their young lives. “Capturing a voice that rings true to a teenager is hard to do and really important. You have to capture situations that are interesting and also universal. That’s why so many books have similar themes of loneliness, isolation, feelings of not fitting in,” she says, adding that it’s also an exciting age group in that kids are open to exploring different ideas and different forms.

Although she has no teenagers in her own life, she says that she remembers her own experience powerfully, and the sense of loneliness she felt in her teens “is still always with me in some ways.” The novel is not autobiographical per se, but has many parallels to Sandell’s life: growing up in a small town with few Jews and being very aware of her identity, spending a summer during college in Israel on a kibbutz and falling in love with the country. After graduating from college, she moved to Jerusalem and worked at The Jerusalem Report magazine.

Now 28 and married to an Israeli, Jewish Week Staff Writer Liel Leibovitz, she explains that questions about her own Jewish identity and her relationship to Israel spurred her to write this novel.
— Sandee Brawarsky - Jewish Week Book Critic 

 
Jewish Book World
Narrating this novel in a free verse style that reads like prose, 16-year-old Sarah tells the story of the summer she spends working on an Israeli kibbutz. For an American girl from a small, mainly Christian town in Pennsylvania who considers herself a dork and an outsider, it is a transformative experience. Along with the thrill of belonging as a Jew in a Jewish land, Sarah experiences her first taste of independence and her first romantic encounters with boys. Her impressions of Israel, especially Jerusalem and the Galilee where she works as a kibbutz volunteer, are idealistic, but acute; they will evoke memories in any reader who has already been there and will arouse curiosity in those who haven’t. Her personal growth, achieved with some pain but also with much satisfaction, is beautifully portrayed; Sarah is a character with whom many teenage readers will identify and ultimately, admire. Other characters are seen through her eyes and emerge as distinct and dimensional individuals, especially the two Israeli boys to whom she is attracted. When one of them, a soldier, is killed, Sarah’s almost idyllic summer is shattered and for the first time, she longs for the safety of her home in America. This incident is one of a few that relate to political issues and all of them are dealt with subtly, providing context for a story about living in present-day Israel and background to the lives and feelings of the young Israelis with whom Sarah interacts. The conclusion, once Sarah is back in the United States and applying to colleges, affirms her commitment to Israel and illustrates the options open to almost all Jewish American young people. This is the author’s first novel.  
 
Bookslut
Shifting gears a bit, in The Weight of the Sky, Lisa Ann Sandell has crafted a novel in verse about a high school junior who is overwhelmed by all the choices she must make about her future. This would be a fairly typical situation for any sixteen-year-old except Sarah is also Jewish and decides to find her way on a kibbutz in Israel the summer before her senior year. The decision makes for an engaging series of conflicts both within Sarah and with the people she meets, as she tries to figure out just where she belongs in the world and just how much her religion means in her daily life.

There were a lot of surprises for me in this novel. First, I generally do not like lyrical novels — I like my novels written in complete sentences and keep poetry on an entirely separate shelf. I actually received Weight by accident — thank heavens! — and found that Sarah’s story is so engaging, that every aspect of her summer so quietly enthralling, that the format was fine. What really grabbed me though were the many quiet little dramas that Sarah engages in as she meets distant relatives, tries to understand the strangeness of her surroundings (she’s from Pennsylvania) and finds herself in a couple of romances along the way. Sandell does an excellent job of not shying away from the Israeli/Palestinian Conflict either. While this is certainly not a book about an American caught up in international intrigue, Sarah does have her own thoughts about carrying a gun for your country and finds herself surprised on more than one occasion by the armed conflict reality that she ends up living in. In more ways than one, this is a novel about growing up, and about realizing that there is more to life than how you look in you band uniform back home.

I have not seen many novels that tackle the subject of mainstream religion for teens, or the need to fit in from a perspective like Sarah’s. This is not a religious book, really, which might seem odd to say as it is about a Jewish girl in Israel, but there is no dogma here — no proselytizing about the miracle of turning the deserts green. It’s mostly about the comfort you find surrounded by people who are just like you, on the smaller levels, like people who don’t question what you’re going to eat for lunch in the school cafeteria. And because it is about that most universal of needs — belonging — it has a very wide ranging appeal. (There is a night and day difference between this book and The Queen of Cool, but on some fundamental levels they are remarkably about the same thing, which is the sort of literary synergy that I just love.) The Weight of the Sky should be appreciated on many levels, but most significantly as a book about belonging in the larger world and giving yourself up to the longings you feel in your heart. It’s lovely reading and wholly and completely a book that belongs within the current times.

 
Teensreadtoo.com
Reviewed by: Sally Kruger, aka "Readingjunky"
Rating:  5 Stars
Sarah has just finished her junior year at a high school in Pennsylvania.  As a professed band geek and the only one among her friends who is Jewish, she is always on the outside looking in.  When her parents announce plans to send her to Israel to spend the summer, she's shocked that they would make plans like that without consulting her.  At least that's her initial reaction, because once she starts to really consider the idea, she realizes that might be just the thing she needs to find out who she truly is.

After a brief visit in Jerusalem with relatives, Sarah heads to the kibbutz, where she will spend the remainder of the summer.  Shy and withdrawn, it takes a bit of courage for Sarah to find her place in the group of kibbutz residents and volunteers.  Once she begins working in the fields, sharing meals with the others, and doing some exploring, Sarah finds she is more at home here than back in Pennsylvania.  The land is beautiful and rich with her history and religion.  But underneath the beauty is a violence between people that Sarah just can't quite understand.

Lisa Ann Sandell uses verse to take readers on this self-discovery type journey with Sarah.  I could sense her appreciation and inspiration, yet also feel her confusion as she spends time exploring her native land and heritage. Thoughtful readers will find this a welcome addition to any library shelf.

 
Children's Literature
Imagine being a marching band geek and the only Jew in your class. For Sarah Green, a junior in high school, this is her reality. Sarah is a bright girl who has applied to Ivy League schools and is getting ready to go to college. She has a lot to learn about life first. Her parents send her to Israel for the summer to work on a kibbutz and to meet some of her relatives. What she finds in Israel will change her life forever. Sarah falls for two boys in Israel. The first, Loir, she meets right away. After wonderful conversations and a few kisses, he has to go to serve his country. Then Sarah leaves her Aunt's house and goes to the work camp. Right away she meets Nadav and falls in love. At the end of her experience, she finds out some news regarding Loir. Upon her return to Pennsylvania, this American girl realizes that her roots are planted in Israel where she feels most at home. How do her parents take this news? What draws her to go back is a lot more than Nadav. Can her parents accept her decision? This debut novel is written in free verse and is very easy to read. It is a delightful book that teaches many important issues related to diversity, culture, and relationships. A sure pleasure for reluctant readers as well. 2006, Viking/Penguin, Ages 15 to Adult.
— Kelly Grebinoski
 
Jbooks.com
Reading Lisa Ann Sandell’s The Weight of the Sky, a heartfelt, affecting novel about a sixteen-year-old girl’s first trip to Israel and how it changes her life, brought back memories of my first trip to Israel when I was nineteen: the magical feel of Jerusalem, with its ancient stones and staggering history; the ubiquitous tomato and cucumber salads swimming in olive oil and lemon juice; the 4:30 am kibbutz wakeup call; the kibbutz’s dinner of pink yogurt, bread, and raw vegetables; the shock of seeing massive machine guns casually slung over young soldiers’ shoulders everywhere; and the often mystifying relationship between the Israelis and Palestinians. Sandell also successfully captures the surprise and joy of what it feels like for an American Jew to be, for the first time, in a place where Jews are the majority, where the entire country celebrates the Jewish Sabbath. She shows the profound and often confusing effect that Israel can have on a Jewish person’s life.What makes The Weight of the Sky particularly unique is that it’s a novel in free verse. I hadn’t read a novel in verse in many years, and the ones I have read are primarily of the ancient Greek variety, or sonnet sequences such as Marilyn Hacker’s beautiful and unforgettable Love, Death, and the Changing of the Seasons. The poetry of Sandell’s novel isn’t in a classical form; it’s a narrative free verse that’s a bit like prose, with line breaks every few words; if the line breaks were taken out, many of the sentences would read like traditional prose. It’s a form that isn’t easy to carry off, but Sandell does it very well.Sandell is at her best when she describes the little details of Israeli life: prayer notes falling out of the Western Wall when Sarah, the narrator, tries to stick her note in; Sarah’s difficulty in understanding Israeli Hebrew, which is so different from what she studied in Hebrew school; and the strange cultural pull she feels for this homeland. Even though Sarah isn’t particularly religious—she’s unsure of her own faith in God, and though her family is kosher, and goes to synagogue twice a year, she says that “I sense/for my parents it’s more about/tradition than/spirituality/or faith”—being in Israel is the first time she feels a sense of belonging….

Sandell also powerfully describes Sarah’s coming of age—her first kiss, her first boyfriend, the first time she feels accepted by the group of older teens and early-twenty-somethings who work on the kibbutz. Sarah is an articulate narrator, mature enough to recognize how young she is, and how much she has yet to learn, and how she’s not ready to have sex yet….

I read The Weight of the Sky in two ways: as my former teenage self, who would’ve loved it unabashedly, and as a slightly jaded (though trying not to be) adult reader. Both the teenage reader and the adult reader in me enjoyed the book very much. The adult side, however, recognized that a novel in verse is not for every reader, and I imagine young adults might be more open-minded than some adult readers to a novel in poetry. Very few poetry books, novels or not, are published by large adult publishing houses, who take as their credo that poetry simply does not sell. It’s a credit to both young adult publishers, and young adult readers, that they seem to be more open to the poetic form. Credit is due to writers who take risks as well, and who are willing to write narrative free verse, a form that gives so much weight to individual words that it can seem cloying or overdone. But Sandell’s writing never hits a false note. It’s honest and sincere, and The Weight of the Sky should be required reading for any young woman going to Israel for the first time, or any adult reader who would love to revisit that early life-altering experience.

 
Bookideas.com
The Weight of the Sky is written solely in free verse—a popular form of poetry that does not rhyme nor does it have a meter. Its popularity stems from the belief that free verse is poetry without rules. Moreover, it is different from prose or poetry in the arrangement of carefully chosen words into verses.

Lisa Ann Sandell's debut novel The Weight of the Sky is powerful in its simplicity. What is more amazing is that the entire story is written in verse, no small feat by any means! The characters are very much alive as are the settings, both in the flashbacks in Pennsylvania and in Israel.

The narrative focuses on a simple plot involving an insecure sixteen -year-old Sarah, the only Jew in her class in Pennsylvania, who is sent to violence-torn Israel for a summer vacation. Gradually, she falls in love with the country, despite the brutality, the shootings in the streets and bombs going off on buses that that are reported daily news broadcasts. Lior and Nadaf, two handsome soldiers help her on the road from insecure adolescence to maturity. Harsh life on Kibbutz Kfar Avivim makes her want to return to her cozy home in Pennsylvania, but the beauty surrounding her, the smells, the sounds, and the friendships, override her homesickness.

Sandell's writing can be compared to a beautiful painting with all the attributes of a master painter. She brings tears to your eyes with the contrast of so much beauty and yet so much sadness.

The Weight of the Sky should not be limited to the Young Adult audience. Everyone should read and enjoy the beautiful free verse written by such a talented author.